Thanks to a Marcelo who, in a comment, turned me on to the Temple Grandin film. Holy Cow! It was great! I also listened to the commentary, which featured autism victim and cattle pen designer Temple Grandin herself...and I took some notes, which I'll reproduce here. Most of them are a simple statement of what Grandin believes, which may not be news to her fans, but should interest those who don't know much about her. I'll end with my own thoughts.
I love Grandin's way of thinking, which is so practical. She notices that cattle are comforted by snug confinement on the sides, and figures that humans would probably react the same way. She made a "squeeze machine" for herself and used it to calm herself when she got anxiety attacks. If you're autistic, that's a big deal. Thanks to Grandin you can buy these things on the internet. It's important, though, that the user controls the experience.
- She's not alarmed when autistics do repetitive motions. She says it's their way of shaking off sensory overload. They can be taught to limit it to, say, an hour a day.
She continues to take anti-anxiety pills, preferring old types that are cheap and in the public domain now.
- Visible autistic behavior lessens as you get older, maybe because you have more experiences to draw from by then. She says autistic kids desperately need frequent social and educational stimulation, but not to the point of overload. Teach kids even if they don't appear to be learning. Prompt them to memorize.
- Autistic kids respond well to animals. Odd that they don't seem to mind animals touching them, just humans.
That's it for the notes. I wish I could ask Grandin about some things that weren't in the film. She makes a good case for tactile and picture learning, but how would she teach abstract subjects like algebra and French to autistics? In the commentary she says she would have autistics bypass algebra and go directly to geometry and trig, which are visual. Hmmm, maybe, but what about French?
The subject interests me because I was always an unexciting "C" student in these subjects (algebra and French), even though they interested me. I could never figure out my resistance to them. There must be a better way to teach this stuff, but I have no idea what it would be.
Decades later I developed a taste for French rhetoric and musical lyrics. I like the sound of them even though I don't know what they mean. I'll do a blog about my favorites soon, and see if you don't feel the same way. As long as you know a little about pronunciation, you'll find yourself compulsively reading these stirring and romantic texts out loud.
Autism interests me because people who are victims of it, and who succeed in spite of it, are forced to learn everything in an unconventional way. It's an insight into another way of learning and thinking. Maybe there's something there that could help normal people too.
BTW, I like the way Claire Danes looks in the film (left). Maybe it's the hair.
Here's (left) the way she wears it when she's being herself. She looks like a different person. I prefer the film look. Straight hair isn't for everybody.
I wanna see her try to put Mike Fontanelli in the hug box!
ReplyDeleteFascinating post, Eddie. Seems like the type of autism that Ms. Grandin has is a little bit more extreme tahn whatever I have. I've never even had to take anti-anxiety pills before, but I did forgot to mention that for a long time, I was extremely shy around other people, even though I could talk to them when I had to. Hopefully, whenever I meet you or John K. someday in person (sorry if that sounds a bit creepy, but I'm serious, and it may happen sooner than you think), you won't think of me as that type of person. Trust me, I've come a long way.
ReplyDeleteThose cow photos are funny.
ReplyDeleteHer movie hair looks like she's auditioning for Annie.
ReplyDeleteWow, I didn't know about this film. I just ordered it at my public library. I'm 280th in line to see it. This'll take a while.
ReplyDeleteIt's kind of a shame that HBO didn't have the nerve to have someone not-beautiful play her. They chickened out in the same way with Joyce Brabner in American Splendor.
Steve: Haw!
ReplyDeleteLester: I used to think that way, but now i've been won over to using beautiful faces. That insures that investers get their money back and the industry stays healthy. It also lends a mythic dimension to the story.
Roberto: You must have had a pretty mild case. Either that or your parents got you first class treatment when you were young.
Rooni: I like those cow pictures, too. Who'd have thought that cows were so photogenic?
It must be especially difficult for an actor to portray an autistic person. It's like the opposite of "method" acting.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, I finally finished The Fountainhead. It took me a little over a month to read, but I loved Ayn Rand's style of writing and how deep each character in her book was, especially Ellsworth Toohey and his boss, Gail Wynand, who I both loved to hate so much because of their absolute selfishness and how they treated Howard Roark all throughout the novel, even though in my opinion, he came across as a humble genius of architecture. I also saw the 1949 film with Gary Cooper the other day, and I thought of it as a good supplement to such a great read, although the swearing and the gritty language didn't appear to make it so much in the movie (I'm guessing it had something to do with the Hays Code at that time).
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to get started on the other few books you recommended to me in that other post a while back.
Ed Grimley was an actor portraying an autistic person, wasn't he?
ReplyDelete